Back

                         TEAK SUBSTITUTES

                                                                     THIN ON THE GROUND BUT DEFINITELY AROUND

 

                             A consideration of the breadth of uses to which TECTONA GRANDIS (TEAK) can be put demonstrates just how

                             important this timber is to be timber trade.

 

                             Teak is used for ship and boat building, for decking, for rails and hatches. In the furniture trade it tis used

                             for  fine furniture and cabinet making, interior and exterior joiner, flooring and garden furniture.

 

                             The most prized Burmese Teak is a uniform golden brown colour without makings. Most other Teak is rich

                             brown with darker chocolate brown markings.

 

                            I am told that log to board conversion is truly turning a pigs ear into a silk purse as the logs are  generally        

                            gnarled and unattractive. However there is very little waste at the mill as even small off cuts are used for

                            turnings and ornaments.

 

                           Teak has a "very durable" classification. Its other outstanding qualities include a high strength grading,

                           widely recognised stability in service and its resistance to fire and acid.

 

                          Like Oak and Mahogany, Teak is a "benchmark" timber against which others are often judged in relation to 

                          specific applications.

 

                          In recent years however supplies have become less reliable and the price of Teak has blown out to the point 

                          where it is reasonable to consider other less expensive and more accessible species which have similar 

                          applications.

 

                         In particular, an Australian user might consider VITEX ( also known as "New Guinea Teak") and IROKO

                         ( also  called Odum and "African Teak").

 

                          Further on Iroko, it must be said that for strength, durability and stability, all reliable authorities confirm

                          that this timber compares favourable for marine work with Teak. In appearance Iroko is generally very

                          similar in colour tone. Iroko is easier to work with cutting tools - as it does not have the silica content

                          present in Teak.

 

 

                     The following table provides some bases for comparison:

 

                         SPECIES                       TEAK                                       VITEX                                      IROKO

 

                        Tree Ht ( M)                     40                                            33                                            50

 

                         Weight ( lb / ft3)           40                                           45/55                                       40

 

                         Mechanical                  Hard                                    Heavy & moderately                  Medium

                          Properties                                                               hard

 

                                                       Medium density                          Dense                                        Medium density

 

                                                      Medium bending                         Bends well                                 Medium bending

 

                                                      High crushing                            High crushing                            Medium crushing

 

                                                      Low stiffness                              Medium stiffness                        Very low stiffness

 

                                                      Low movement                            Low  to medium                          Small movement

                                                      in service                                    movement in service                 in service

 

 

                       Working                      Medium resistance               Moderately difficult to                Satisfactory with

                        Properties                  severely blunts cutters          cut but planes to                        moderate to severe

                                                                                                           smooth finish                            blunting on edges.

 

 

                       Durability                    Very durable                          Heartwood very durable             Heartwood very

                                                                                                                                                              Durable

 

                       Colour                         Golden Brown                         Grey Olive,                                 Golden orange

                                                                                                            Yellow - brown                            to brown

         

 

                        I have relied for these technical comparisons on various texts including:

 

                         - World Woods In Colour                                                                                         McMillan

                        - The International Book Of Wood                                                                         Mitchell Beazley

                        - Characteristics, Properties & Uses of Timber

                        - " South East Asia, Northern Australia and The Pacific"                                    Inkata

                        - Timbers of the British Solomon Islands                                                             Levers Pacific Ltd

 

                        These sources make it clear that VITEX is use for boat building, ribs, stringers, keelsons and planking and

                        that is "highly regarded in New Guinea for these purposes". Vitex is being increasingly introduced into our

                        own market and its attractive price will see it used much more readily in the future for purposes formerly

                        reserved for Teak and it is available in a range of sizes.

 

                        It could not be said however that Vitex resembles Teak in appearance and this is where the attraction of

                        Iroko probably lies.

 

                       Iroko (from West Africa) is used for ship and boat building as well as for high class joinery. The expressions 

                      "African Teak" and "Poor mans Teak" have variously been used to describe Iroko which is so dense that it is a 

                       favoured timber for laboratory bench tops and containers for radioactive materials. Again this timber is 

                       considerably less expensive than Teak.

 

                        B.J. Rendle ("world Timbers") notes that Iroko was harder than Teak but slightly inferior in other strength  

                       properties. It definitely has a superficial resemblance to Teak but the distinction lies in its far coarser grain

                       and absence of a greasy surface, so familiar in sawn Teak. Iroko does not bend as well as teak and its

                       classification for steam bending would be "moderate". Iroko is as resistant to Termite attack as Teak.

 

                       On exposure to the weather as ships decking, garden furniture etc, Iroko bleaches in much the same way

                       as does Teak.

 

                       Iroko has a high resistance to both insect and fungal attack and the clearest demonstration of its durability 

                       lies in its uses which include coachwork, ships bridges, decking and in West Africa, for sleepers. It is 

                       suitable for flooring, stairs and flooring under which heating is used. This timber is also reported to be "fire 

                       resistant".

 

                       For those who can both afford and find it, Teak will probably always be the answer to a wide range of boat

                        building requirements. There are however a growing range of less costly and readily available alternatives 

                       which can now be considered. As they say in the ad - "Please consider"

 

                       Back