Back            

                   MAHOGANIES - A COMPARISON

 

                         What has an African tribe got to do with naming of a timber first shipped to Europe from Jamaica? Read on for the       

                         answers.

 

                        For several centuries, ships made of Mahogany have traversed the globe, one, the mysterious " Mahogany Ship "  

                        allegedly coming to rest at Port Fairy, Victoria long before Captain Cook ventured into southern seas. Mahogany  

                        tables, desks and carvings now enhance the finest dining rooms, boardrooms offices and galleries in the world.            

                        In our homes, furniture made from Mahogany adds a sense of warmth to any room.

 

                        The origins of the two main Mahogany species, from Central and South America and from Africa, are a source of 

                        interest.

 

                       There are no Mahogany forests. The tree is scattered here and there and a good "stand " might be an average of two 

                       trees to the acre.

 

                       History suggests that in 1595 Queen Elizabeth was so taken with South  American Mahogany timber brought to

                       England  by Sir Walter Raleigh that she commissioned his ship's carpenter to make her a Mahogany table. This is  

                       suggested to be the first Mahogany used in England.

 

                      The name Mahogany emanated from the island of Jamaica after the English occupation in 1655. members of the  

                      Nigerian Yoruba tribe brought to Jamaica as slaves, who were familiar with the name for African Mahogany           

                      ( " Oganwo " - meaning " King of the Timber " ), would logically have used the expression " M'Oganwo " for a Jamaican  

                      tree which closely resembled the tree of their Nigerian homeland. After variable usage the name "Mahogany" finally  

                      emerged in 1700.

 

                       Characteristics:

 

                       Sources suggest that the weather beaten log unloaded at the mill gives little hint of the beauty that lies within. 

                       Leading  texts provide the following statistics and details which assist in a comparison :

 

                                        AFRICAN MAHOGANY                           CENTRAL AMERICAN MAHOGANY.

                                        (Khaya Ivorensis)                                    ( Swietenia Macrophylla)

 

                       Heartwood:          Light to deep red / brown                        Light to dark red / brown

 

                       Grain :                 Straight to interlocked                             Straight to interlocked medium to coarse and

                                                   coarse to medium cross                           uniform white or dark gum deposits.

                                                   Fractures or heartbreaks common.

 

                      Weight :               540590 kg/ m3                                       540 -  640 kg /m3

                                                     34 -   36 lb / ft3                                            34 -    40 lb / ft3

 

                      Mechanical       Low bending strength.                               Low bending strength.

                       Properties:       Low shock resistance.                               Very low shock resistance.

                                                 Medium crushing strength                       Medium crushing strength.

                                                                                                                    Moderately good steam bending (better than Khaya)

 

                        Durability:      Moderate. Liable to insect                          Extremely durable but liable to attack by

                                            attack.                                                         beetle and pinhole borers.

 

                       Uses:               Furniture & cabinet making                       High class furniture and cabinet making, pattern

                                              office, shop & banking fitting,                       making and carving, reproduction furniture.

                                              Interior joinery, boat building                       (Other uses identical to African Mahogany).

                                          and vehicle bodies.

 

                       West Indian Mahogany originally came to prominence not only for its colour, lustre, figure and capability of taking a  

                       high polish but also because of its mechanical properties which include relative hardness minimal shrinkage and      

                       its  considerable repulsion for beetles responsible for worm holes.

 

                       The genuine African Mahogany tree closely resembles the South American species both in foliage, flowers, seed 

                       cases,  seeds and in the timber itself. Both belong to the Meliaceae family and can be confined even to the same      

                       sub - division of that family but to different genera - the African being of the Khaya species and the Central 

                       American  being  Swietenia.

 

                       Perhaps the most common " fault " associated with Mahogany is " shake"  marks found in African Mahogany. The 

                      cause  of this problem is not certain but it is more common in highly figured timber and can obviously be a cause of  

                      disappointment as the shakes are rarely visible until the timber has been dressed.

 

                      Tests carried out by the U.S Forest Products Laboratory supplied the following comparative results as between   

                      Khaya African) and Swietenia ( Central American ) Mahogany:

 

                       1-      South American Mahogany is naturally heavier and in its unseasoned state has a greater moisture  

                         content.

 

                      2-      African Mahogany has slightly higher shrinkage rate in the course of drying.

 

                      3-      The impact strength of both timbers is about equal.

 

                      4-      The compression strength of South American Mahogany is generally superior.

 

                      5-     The hardness of both timbers is roughly comparable.

 

                      6-     The " shearing " strength of African Mahogany could be greater.

 

                      To find the essential reason for the universal acceptance of Mahogany one need not look past the state of antique 

                      furniture. While it is true that many other woods lose their beauty ( or have been attacked by borers) a well cared       

                      for mahogany piece often seems to be enhanced with age.

 

                      It is generally regarded that the Mahogany timber from the upper Amazon is firmer and heavier than that of Central 

                      American Mahogany and that it is preferred for carving by some. Conversely, Central American Mahogany produces 

                      more figure logs.

 

                       By contrast African Mahogany is generally more lavishly figure than other Mahogany. The figure varies from 

                      dramatic ribbon grain to complex figures of mottle, crotch and swirl.

 

                      Plantation grown Mahogany.

 

                      Spasmodic and limited supplies of plantation grown Swietenia Macrophylla is available from various Pacific Island  

                      sources: Supplies are limited and intermittent. One of the better potential sources has recently prohibited the export 

                      of the this timber indefinitely.

 

                     The plantation Swietenia timber varies markedly from it's Central American " parent " in the sense that it is busy 

                     with knots formed from regular branch lopping in the immature tree. Depending upon your point of view. Tradesmen 

                     occasionally complain that the plantation timber is unstable. One reason for this may be the likelihood that the 

                     timber is cut form relatively immature tress.

 

 

                     The " Other " Mahoganies  -  Look a likes or imposters?

 

                    From time to time, marketing technique and physical similarities have caused timber merchants to use the term 

                   "Mahogany " in connection with a product. As Gifford (1944) wrote, " Mahogany is so well and favourably known that 

                    many other woods have taken its name ".

                    Some which readily spring to mind include

 

                   1-      " Philippine Mahogany "   (from the Dipterocarpaceae family)

                         This timber is now difficult to obtain but in truth was more like light red Meranti than a true Mahogany. 

                         It was generally paler and more open grained than both African and South American Mahogany.

 

                  2-         Rose "Mahogany"   ( Dysoxylum fraseranum)

                         A beautiful dark red Australian species. One problem in working (the classification is "moderate"  working  

                         qualities), is the oily exudate which can be removed with alcohol. In contrast with the true Mahoganies,          

                         this species is very slow to dry and dries with some end and facial splitting.

 

                 3-         Southern " Mahogany" Gum   (Eucalytus Botryoides)

                         A red/ pink Eucalypt which has good strength qualities and is used in both furniture and structural work.  

                         Certainly this timber has its own attractions but a real Mahogany it is not!

 

                         Some additional comments about African Mahogany:

 

                        It is noteworthy that one respected author (B.J. Rendle  -  " World Timbers "  comments that " since supplies from   

                        the  tropical American region have fallen off, the term " Mahogany "  -  without qualification - in specifications and 

                        description of furniture, joinery etc. generally means African Mahogany.

 

                       Sapele Mahogany or Sapele wood is the term applied to a Mahogany type timber originally shipped from the  

                       Nigerian port of Sapele. This is not a Khaya species and the timber is generally heavier, harder and has a finer 

                       texture than  African Mahogany. Past experiences indicate that this timber does not lend itself well to air - drying 

                       in hot dry Victorian summers and it is certainly less stable than African Mahogany.

 

                      One Khaya species K. Grandifolia is much harder and heavier than general run of African Mahogany and its uses   

                      vary accordingly (eg. Counter tops and block flooring)

 

                      Overview:

 

                      While the reputation for mystique, charm and grandeur remains with Central and South American Mahogany, its 

                      place is being taken over by African Mahogany. The latter species is clearly less expensive, available in a greater 

                     range of sizes, generally more accessible and arguably possesses significantly more attractive character and colour 

                     than the " M'Oganwo " tree, first named by African slaves abandoned in Jamaica by their Spanish captors 350 years 

                     ago.

 

                      Source:

 

                     World Woods In Colour                                  William A. Lincoln                 ( Macmillan)

                     Timbers of The World                                   Alexander L. Howard              ( Macmillan)

                     Wood In Australia                                         Keith Bootle                            ( McGraw - Hill)

                     The Mahogany Book                                     George Lamb                          ( Mahogany association Inc)

                    Mahogany of Tropical American                  F. Bruce Lamb                        ( University of Michagan Press)

 

                  Back